Such Doctors, Hospitals Need to Be Punished

10 Feb
2007

It was shocking to read that the Fortis Hospital in NOIDA refused to hand over the body of a dead patient because the family failed to pay the dues.

It was a simple leg fracture but the patient, Sukhbir Singh Chauhan, died mysteriously in the elite hospital. Not only that, the expense, that was to be Rs. 40,000, swelled up to Rs. 6,50,000. A reason was given neither for the death, nor for the fee.

This is purely criminal neglect and such doctors and hospitals need to be taught a severe lesson. The problem here in India is that doctors treat their patients quite condescendingly, and there is no reason for such a treatment, especially in the private hospitals where they charge exorbitant fee.

Now and again there rises a debate on whether there should be a client/consultant relationship between doctors and patients, or whether there is something extremely holistic about the relationship.

Holistic my foot. Just go to a private hospital and they won’t even see you without a payment slip, so what sort of holistic feeling they talk about? They are just a bunch of hypocrites who want the best of both the worlds. They charge like consultants but when they screw up they say they shouldn’t be treated like the normal service providers and hence shouldn’t be made to bear the responsibility if something unfortunate happens to the patient.

I’m not saying treating a person is same as filing a tax return for your client. Of course it is a matter of life and death when it comes to the service of doctors but this makes it more important to hold them responsible if they are mercenary, callous and careless, as it happened in the Fortis case. Something bad kept on happening to the patient and they didn’t find it necessary important to tell the family while having no qualms about asking for money repeatedly. This is highly moronic on their part.

It’s very scary that you can die of even a smaller injury just because you are unlucky to have bumped into lousy doctors.



You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

2 Responses to “Such Doctors, Hospitals Need to Be Punished”

  1. Novie

    I just discovered your blog. I read a number of entries, and now I plan to become a regular reader. I enjoyed your reflections and commentary about religion, politics, and life in general. I live in a fishing village in eastern Canada, so you can imagine that my life is very different from yours. At the moment, I am trying to stay warm and keep my driveway clear of snow.

    Thanks for publishing such an interesting weblog.

  2. Shachi K

    Yeah It is so disgusting and miserable in the nation like India, where we Indians always poised “Duty Over Everything Else”…I guess we should cry out to have loads of Munnabhai, who can even make the death of the patient peaceful instead of such criminal act…today’s doctors have forgotten their FIRST oath to treat patients with genuine efforts…i dunno if we may ever have “real treatment” and “real doctors” in near future…

    Before prescription, doc will hand over you a hefty bill to pay….whr has that kind heart lost????? More we are trying to clutch shining India through materialistic developments more due to failing moral values in new breed of medical practitioners our faith on today’s medical facility is fading. Otherwise why do our ex-PM had a need to go abroad for his knee replacement…in fact during my last visit to a seminar in AIIMS disclosed the fact that AIIMS did have the facility to get that job done with finesse but may be the public’s faith in them has gone astray. The doc admitted “we could have done the replacement with full expertise” but perhaps Mr. Vajpayee might have no faith on them.

    I want to say after listening and witnessing such incidents “DOCTORS CAN THE INDIANS TRUST U??????… CAN I LISTEN ANY “YES???…???? (I wonder!)

Leave a Reply