Similarity between Kishore Kumar and Amitabh Bachchan
|
14 Jun
2008 |
This thought came to me when I was listening to Darde dil, darde jigar, dil mai jagaya aapne – a Rafi song from the film Karz that became a hit in the mid-70s. This song explains why Mohammad Rafi’s career had begun to recede while Kishore Kumar was still doing great. Rafi not at all sounds good in this song. Listen to the song:
He sounds bland especially in the lower notes (not to sound boastful I can sing this song better). Compared to that listen to this Kishore Kumar song from Mr. India:
Kishore Kumar must have sung Kaate nahi kat-te almost after 15 years Rafi sang Darde dil and still, he sounds sizzling, just like Roop tera mastana from Aradhna. Kishore Kumar knew how to adapt and still sound classy. Although I’m a die-hard Rafi fan I think after a certain period his singing lost relevance and he was still trapped in the golden age of Man tarpat hari darshan ko aaj and Kuhu-kuhu bole koyaliya – renditions that only Rafi could deliver, of course. Savor both the songs:
Rafi was no doubt the playback god of Indian cinema but his singing style couldn’t adapt to the changing times. Kishore Kumar did this with great ease and was a successful singer till his last breath. He even sang exceptionally well for those cheap Jitendra flicks produced by south Indian producers.
This is exactly what Amitabh Bachchan does when all his contemporaries have vanished into the oblivion. In the 70s and 80s he hit the right cord and became a mega star. Even these days his roles are as contemporary as it gets. So what’s common between Kishore Kumar and Amitabh Bachchan? The ability to adapt.
Adaptability can help you in any sphere of life. When you can easily and quickly adapt, you can survive under any condition.
Email this link | Posted by Amrit | Tags: About Movies, Life
Add to: Digg | Del.icio.us | StumbleUpon | Mixx | Yahoo! | Netvouz | BlinkList | Furl

RSS Feeds


June 15th, 2008 at 4:55 am
I agree with you that Rafi and the song were jarring to the ears ( I simply cannot stand the interlude music and ohh the full song arrangement )…Pyare bhai spoilt Laxmi’s wonderful tune. I think LP created amazing tunes ( I consider them to be one of the best in the industry ) but the orchestration took a beating in most of them.
Only correction is that Rafi sang this song only 8 years prior to Kaante Nahin - and Rafi saab was elder to Kishore by 3.8 years.
I always like to keep facts straight.
June 15th, 2008 at 3:55 pm
Thanks for the corrections
June 22nd, 2008 at 12:08 am
[…] to Darde dil, darde jigar, dil mai jagaya aapne ?? a Rafi song from the film Karz that became ahttp://www.writingcave.com/similarity-between-kishore-kumar-and-amitabh-bachchan/Governor lauds bio’s ‘brain power’ San Diego Union-TribuneGov. Arnold Schwarzenegger yesterday […]
October 2nd, 2008 at 6:57 am
Yes u are correct! rafi could not render this perfectly alsothe orchestration is bad. Similarly rafi rendered “maine pucha chandse” rom abdulla also very badly (worse than this).
rafi also renerd very badly from maitabh ” are he oonchi oonchi bato se kisika pet bharata nahi” trying to mitate Kishore. but even kishore though renderd o sathi re very good could n’t make it his est rendition.similarly the enditionof kishore for “salame ihshq ” is not very good. but he sooden realized and imroved by superb renditions in “kab tak andhere chalate ahenge”, “manzile apni jagah ai etc”